Wilma's Tea Cosy

4 Old Lake Rd, Valley Cottage, NY 10989, United States
+1 845-729-8722
$$$ Cafe
(46 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Welcome to Wilma's Tea Cosy, a charming café nestled in the heart of Valley Cottage, NY, where every visit feels like a warm embrace. Located at 4 Old Lake Rd, this delightful tea house stands out not only for its inviting ambiance but also for its commitment to serving exceptional tea and scrumptious food.

As you step through the doors, you're greeted by a cozy atmosphere decorated with whimsical teapots and a curated book selection that beckons for lazy afternoons spent with a cup in hand. The café radiates a sense of community, enhanced by the friendly staff who treat every guest like family.

The menu at Wilma’s is a treasure trove of flavors, showcasing a delightful combination of traditional tea offerings alongside unique and heartwarming dishes. Guests can indulge in classic sandwiches, scones, and decadent cakes. Standout dishes such as the savory beef and potato stew provide a hearty option perfect for any day, as confirmed by customer Dee Kelly, who praised its comforting nature. Many have also raved about the innovative vegetable jollof rice and cucumber dill sandwiches, which are not only fresh but packed with flavor, as experienced by Joanna G and Malka Korenblit. Each bite is a testament to the kitchen's dedication to quality and taste.

But it’s not just the food that dazzles — the tea selection is nothing short of extraordinary. Guests can explore a variety of blends, from Oh Columbia tea that enchants with its depth to the inviting notes of Ghana gold with hints of cacao. Families, like the Thomases, have enjoyed themed tea parties, choosing their favorite unique teapots, making each sip a delightful experience.

The warm and friendly staff, noted in multiple reviews, ensures that every visitor leaves with a smile. Whether you're munching on the delicious sandwiches and desserts or sipping on exquisite teas, the service at Wilma’s elevates the experience to new heights. Guests have shared memorable experiences of taking home leftover treats beautifully wrapped, a testament to the thoughtful touches Wilma’s adds to your visit.

Wilma's Tea Cosy isn't just a café; it’s a celebration of flavors, community, and warmth, making it a must-visit spot for locals and travelers alike. Whether you’re seeking a cozy corner to read, a gathering place to enjoy casual conversation, or a unique experience to share with loved ones, Wilma’s welcomes you with open arms and a pot of freshly brewed joy.

Don’t miss out on the chance to find your new favorite tea haven. Call them today at +1 845-729-8722 for inquiries or simply drop by to see what your taste buds have been missing!

Service options
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great tea selection
Popular for
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Dessert
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Parking
Free parking lot
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

11:30 AM - 07:30 PM

Wednesday

11:30 AM - 07:30 PM

Thursday

11:30 AM - 07:30 PM

Friday

11:30 AM - 07:30 PM

Saturday

11:30 AM - 07:30 PM

Sunday

11:30 AM - 04:30 PM

46 Reviews
Asia Perez

20 Sep 2025

I came here for my birthday and i had such a good time! I can’t wait to come back. All the food was delicious the rice was my favorite very flavorful! And I loved the Oh Columbia tea!

Dee Kelly

23 Aug 2025

Loved it here!!!!! Such a special new shop, with delicious food and unique offerings I haven’t seen elsewhere in Rockland. I loved my classic tea offerings of sandwiches, scones, and cakes, but also particularly enjoyed the beef and potato stew. It was so hearty and yet not too heavy for a warm day. My tea choice was Ghana gold, and the hint of cacao was delicious. It was delightful to have our own teas each in our own fun teapot and the decorations were vibrant and joyful too! I can’t wait to go back and try some other offerings, as well as purchase some teas to bring home and even some decor items from Ghana also!!

Malka Korenblit

04 Aug 2025

Amazing experience and such a warm welcoming atmosphere! The food was all so delish, highlights were the rice and salmon sandwich- but everything was so flavorful fresh and delicious. I would absolutely go again and highly recommend that anyone who has the chance goes and checks out Wilma’s. Thank you for you warm and kind hospitality :)

Anne Hartkemeyer

22 Jul 2025

Such a beautiful atmosphere and experience. Lovely book selection and delicious everything. Such kind people and a really intentional space. Appreciated the vegetarian options. I bought some loose leaf African tea blend to take home because I loved it so much.

Joanna G

23 Jun 2025

I asked about vegan options and their vegetable jolloff rice was hearty and delicious and perfect at the end of a cold long day. Wilma's cucumber dill sandwich was really great too with avocado spread. They made nice spicy ginger tea for me and the ambiance is very cozy and happy. I recommend Wilma's Tea Cozy for the food and the the kindness.

Sajan Thomas

19 Jun 2025

Our family went for the monthly tea party hosted by Wilma’s Tea Cosy and had a very unique phenomenal experience. The tea flavors available are very exquisite and the experience of being served your tea in a one-of-a-kind tea pot of your choice was wonderful. We enjoyed the Tropical Bang & Hibiscus Ginger teas. Our kids loved the Rooibos Chai & Tangy Orange teas. Great place to catch up with friends. Definitely a must-try for a truly great experience.

Annabella Robb

08 Jun 2025

Wow, this tea house blew us away! Such large portions for a tea house and amazing flavor. Mom and I loved that we could pick our own tea pots - how adorable!! Best of all was the service, the gentleman that waited on us was so kind and attentive. When we finished, he asked if we would like to go cups for our leftover tea. Then he wrapped our left over dessert with a ribbon had such a great time I forgot to take pics there! He had great attention to detail. We will back, thanks so much!

Cappytanns Corner

08 Jun 2025

We had a wonderful time at Wilma’s for some tea and snacks. The tea selection is wonderful and the best part is you get to choose the teapot that your tea is served in. Makes it more interactive. There are packages to choose from that include food for one or two people. The sandwiches were great as well as the jollof rice. The soup of the day was chicken noodle which wasn’t bad. The service is wonderful and you do end up having a great tea time with whoever you go with. There’s also a monthly tea party on the last Sunday of the month that you can make reservations for. There’s plenty of tea shops in nyc, but here’s one of the few in Westchester county.

Join the Wilma's Tea Cosy Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.